Reviews

61 views

What is Enlightenment? Classic Sources of Contemporary Issues

The title of this paper quotes the question posed by the journal Berlinische Monatsschrift in 1784 and answered in that journal by two of the most prominent philosophers of the time: Immanuel Kant and Moses Mendelsohn. Here, I want to distinguish
of 8
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Share
Tags
Transcript
  !"#$ & !"#$ &' ()*&+"$,)-,)$. /*#''&0 12340,' 25 /2)$,-624#47 8''3,' '"( )(#*+ ,$-"./0$(/ 12 3*0"(4/4$+ 5401( 6."+$. 7(48$.+4/9 ' "0 *+4(# "+ /:$ /4/;$ 12 09 /";<=>:"/ 4+ ?(;4#:/$(0$(/@=/:$ A*$+/41( -1+$B C9 /:$ D1*.("; !"#$%&%'()" +,&-.''()#%/.   4( &EFG "(B "(+H$.$B 4( /:"/ D1*.("; C9 /H1 12 /:$ 01+/ -.104($(/ -:4;1+1-:$.+ 12 /:$ /40$I '00"(*$; J"(/ "(B K1+$+ K$(B$;+1:(L M1B"9 ' H"(/ /1 B4+/4(#*4+: /:.$$ 01B$;+ 12 $(;4#:/$(0$(/=/:$ .$-*C;4N"( -*C;4N +-:$.$O /.$"/9 2$B$.";4+0O "(B N.4/4A*$ 12 +/.*N/*."; 4($A*";4/9=4( 1.B$. /1 4(8$+/4#"/$ /:$ .$;"/41(+:4-+ C$/H$$( -"./4N*;". "(B *(48$.+"; /:"/ /:$9 $0C1B9L J"(/P+ B$24(4/41( 12 $(;4#:/$(0$(/ 4+ -.1C"C;9 /:$ 01+/ H4B$;9 <(1H(I " .$;$"+$ 2.10 400"/*.4/9O *(B$.+/11B "+ Q/:$ 4("C4;4/9 /1 *+$ 1($P+ *(B$.+/"(B4(# H4/:1*/ /:$ #*4B"(N$ 12 "(1/:$.LR &  K"/*.4/9 H"+ /1 C$ $S$.N4+$B 4( H:4N: $"N: :"B /:$ Q2.$$B10 /1 0"<$  012$%( 1'" 12 1($P+ .$"+1( 4( ";; 0"//$.+LR T  '2 +*N: " -*C;4N .$";0 N1*;B C$ 4(+/4/*/41(";4U$BO /:$(O :$ /:1*#:/O $(;4#:/$(0$(/ H"+ Q";01+/ 4($84/"C;$R V  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 N$(/*.9 C$21.$ \1:( ]1N<$ N1*;B H.4/$ :4+ 4(2;*$(/4"; 3".."# 4,&("#&%&5 6,$"#-.%,&  4( &[F^L )+ ]$+;4$ ).01*. :"+ -14(/$B 1*/O H:4;$ $".;9 *(48$.+4/4$+ 4( _"("B" H$.$ 21*(B$B C9 _:.4+/4"( B$(104("/41(+O /:$4. /:$1;1#9 2"N*;/4$+ /$(B$B /1 B$2$(B _:.4+/4"(4/9 4( #$($."; ."/:$. /:"( $(/$. B$(104("/41("; N1(/.18$.+4$+L 3$ "//.4C*/$+ /:4+ 2"N/ /1 /:$ ;"N< 12 "( $+/"C;4+:$B N:*.N: 4( _"("B" "(B /:$ ;"N< 12 " B104("(/ +9+/$0 12 C$;4$2L G  '( +4/*"/41(+ H4/:1*/ $22$N/48$ *("(404/9 12 C$;4$2O N10C4($B H4/: /:$ -1++4C4;4/9 1. 0$01.9 12 B$+/.*N/48$ N1(2;4N/O /:$.$ ".4+$+ " 01/48$ /1 /"<$ " B4+/"(N$ 4( 1.B$. /1 .$#".B 1($P+ 1H( H"9 12 ;42$O H4/: 4/+ 1.4$(/4(# C$;4$2+ "(B N1004/0$(/+O "+  71'. ,&" 8-9 #-.)"# .)-& .)" .#1.) %.'"$/  L M:*+O /:$ 24.+/ -"#$ 12 ]1N<$P+ ;$//$. +$/+ "+4B$ /:$ A*$+/41( 12 .$;4#41*+ 1./:1B1S9O (1/4(# /:"/ Q$8$.91($ 4+ 1./:1B1S /1 :40+$;2R "(B ).01*. (1/$+ /:"/ /:$ N1004/0$(/ /1 .$"+1( 4( _"("B4"( /:$1;1#9 +/$0+ 2.10 /:$ 2$". 12 ;1+4(# "B:$.$(/+ /1 " 01.$ 4(/$;;$N/*";;9 .4#1.1*+ +$N/L `  '/ 4+ (1/ +*.-.4+4(# /1 N1(N;*B$ /:"/ /:$ -"4( 12 B4+/"(N4(# 4+ ;4<$;9 /1 C$ 2"N$B 1(;9 42 " #.$"/$. -"4( 4+ $S-$.4$(N$B "+ /:.$"/$(4(#L ,4+/"(N4(# B1$+ (1/ 0$"( .$D$N/4(# C$;4$2 1*/.4#:/ C*/ B4+/4(#*4+:4(# C$/H$$( " 24.+/W;$8$; C$;4$2 12 " N1(/$+/$B +$N/".4"( /9-$ "(B " +$N1(BW;$8$; C$;4$2 12 " 01.$ *(48$.+"; /9-$L M:*+O "+ ).01*. ".#*$+O " B4+/"(N$ 2.10 +$N/".4"( ".#*0$(/+ $(/"4;+ " #.$"/$. 24B$;4/9 /1 /:$ /.*/: 12 _:.4+/4"(4/9  0"# '" L [  >:$( ]1N<$ +*+-$(B+ :4+ C$;4$2 4( +$N/".4"( 1./:1B1S9 "+ /:$ .$"; /.*/: /1 .$#".B 4/ "+ :4+ 8$.+41( 12 /:$ /.*/:O :4+ 24.+/W;$8$; +N$-/4N4+0 N10C4($+ H4/: " +$N1(BW;$8$; "224.0"/41(L M:4+ "224.0"/41( 4+ 4( /:$ 24.+/ -;"N$ /1H".B " (1(W+$N/".4"( _:.4+/4"(4/9O C*/ 4/ ";+1 $0C."N$+ \$H4+: "(B K1+;$0 8$.+41(+ 12 .$8$";$B .$;4#41(L '/ .$"N:$+ 4/+ ;404/O :1H$8$.O 4( "/:$4+0I Q/:1+$ ".$ (1/ "/ ";; /1 C$ /1;$."/$B H:1 B$(9 /:$ C$4(# 12 " a1BL !.104+$+O N18$("(/+ "(B 1"/:+O H:4N: ".$ /:$ C1(B 12 :*0"( +1N4$/9O N"( :"8$ (1 :1;B *-1( "( "/:$4+/LR E  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b11<L 6.10 /:$ 84$H-14(/ 12 /:$ -"4( 4(81;8$B 4( B4+/"(N4(#O " +0";; +/"./ N"( ;$"B 2*./:$. /1H".B 1/:$. $(;4#:/$(4(# *(48$.+";4U"/41(+L Y( /:$ 1/:$. :"(BO " .$2*+"; /1 /"<$ /:4+ +/$- N"( C$ N";;$B 2*(B"0$(/";4+0=/:$ 4(+4+/$(N$ /:"/ /:$ +90C1;4N +/.*N/*.$ /1 H:4N: ' :1;B 4+ H4/:1*/ .$+$.8"/41( /:$ 1(;9 84"C;$ +90C1;4N +/.*N/*.$ /1 B$-4N/ .$";4/9 4/+$;2L >$ N"( -.1C"C;9 ";; +$$ /:"/ 2*(B"0$(/";4+0 8$.+*+ $(;4#:/$(0$(/ 4+ " C"+4N ";/$.("/48$ 12 1*. /40$L 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c-;*.";dW+/"/$L _"("B" 4+ 1($ $S"0-;$L 5$N1(BO +4(N$ *(48$.+";4/9 4+ -;"N$B "/ /:$ ;$8$; 12 /:$ ("/41(W+/"/$O /:$.$ 4+ (1 N1(N$-/41( 12 :*0"( *(48$.+";4/9 /:"/ /."(+N$(B+ /:$ +/"/$L >:4;$ J"(/ B4B :"8$ " N1(N$-/41( 12 4(/$.("/41("; -$"N$O :$ /:1*#:/ /:"/ /:$ ("/*."; 4(/$.("/41("; N1(B4/41( H"+ 1($ 12 H". "(B "//$0-/$B /1 B$.48$ -$"N$ $SN;*+48$;9 2.10 " 0*/*"; +$;2W4(/$.$+/ 4( "814B4(# H".L F  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   /:"/ N1(N$.(+ 0"( "+ 0"( 4+ 1&%<"#'-$  O H4/:1*/ B422$.$(N$ 4( ."(<e /:$ :&$%5)."&;"&.   12 0"( N1(+4B$.$B "+ N4/4U$( 01B424$+ H4/: #-&=   "(B  0#,/"''%,& LR ^  M:4+ ;"//$. 4+ H:"/ J"(/ B$(4$BO 12 N1*.+$e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  !"#$ G $(;4#:/$(0$(/ /:"/ 4+ (1/ +/.*N/*.$B "+ " 018$ *-H".B 2.10 0$.$ -"./4N*;".4/9 /1H".B " +$N1(BW;$8$;O +:".$B *(48$.+";4/9 +*N: "+ ]1N<$ "(B J"(/ "++*0$@ K$(B$;+1:( +*##$+/+ /:"/ /:$.$ 0"9 C$ " N1(2;4N/ C$/H$$( :*0"( *(48$.+";4/9 "(B $(;4#:/$(0$(/ H4/:4( " #48$( +/"/$ C$N"*+$ /:$ #48$( +/"/$ B1$+ (1/ B4++$04("/$ $(;4#:/$(0$(/ /:.1*#:1*/ 4/+ $(/4.$ +1N4$/9O 1. N"((1/ B1 +1 H4/:1*/ -$.4+:4(#L 3$.$O :$ +"9+O Q-:4;1+1-:9 0*+/ <$$- +4;$(/LR M:4+ 4+O ' /:4(<O C$N"*+$ K$(B$;+1:( *(B$.+/11B /:"/ :*0"( *(48$.+";4/9 .$A*4.$+ -"./4N*;". .11/+ "(B /:"/ /:1+$ -"./4N*;". .11/+O +*N: "+ ("/41(+O N"((1/ C$ +40-;9 $;404("/$B $8$( 42 /:$9 N1(/"4( 4($."B4N"C;$ C"..4$.+ /1 $(;4#:/$(0$(/ 12 /:$ H:1;$ -1-*;"/41(L 3$ N"*/41(+ *+ /:"/ Q42 1($ N"((1/ B4++$04("/$ N$./"4( /.*/:+ /:"/ ".$ *+$2*; "(B 1.("0$(/ 0"( H4/:1*/ /$".4(# B1H( /:$ -.4(N4-;$+ 12 .$;4#41( "(B $/:4N"; ;42$ ($N$++".4;9 "NN10-"(94(# :40O /:"/ H"9 /:$ 84./*$W;184(# 0"( 12 ?(;4#:/$(0$(/ H4;; -.1N$$B H4/: N"*/41( "(B N".$ "(B ."/:$. /1;$."/$ /:$ -.$D*B4N$ /:"( B.48$ /:$ /.*/: "H"9 /:"/ 0"9 C$ 4(/$./H4($B H4/: 4/LR M1 /."(+;"/$ 4(/1 " N1(/$0-1.".9 4B410I 42 H$ 24(B " N*;/*."; -."N/4N$ N1(/.".9 /1 /:$ $(;4#:/$(0$(/ "(B $A*";4/9 12 ";;O H$ +:1*;B C$ N".$2*;O 4( N.4/4N4U4(# /:"/ -."N/4N$O (1/ ";+1 /1 B$+/.19 /:$ N;"40+ /1 *(48$.+";4/9 H4/:4( /:"/ N*;/*.$L ' H4;; #1 1( /1 B4+"#.$$ H4/: K$(B$;+1:( C9 +*##$+/4(# " H"9 4( H:4N: -:4;1+1-:9 N"( +-$"< "/ /:4+ -14(/O C*/ ' H1*;B (1/ H"(/ /1 21.#$/ :4+ .$04(B$. /1 -.1N$$B H4/: N".$ "(B N"*/41(L K$(B$;+1:( .$N1#(4U$B /:"/ H$ ;48$ 4( " H1.;B 4( H:4N: $S-.$++41(+ 12 :*0"( *(48$.+";4/9O H:4N: H$ N";; $(;4#:/$(0$(/O ".$ ";H"9+ $0C$BB$B 4( -"./4N*;". N*;/*."; .11/+ "(B /:"/ *(48$.+";4/9 N"((1/ +*.848$ H4/:1*/ +*N: -"./4N*;". .11/+L >$ N"( ($8$. C$ -*.$;9 *(48$.+"; C$4(#+O (1. /:4(<$.+O C*/ ".$ ";H"9+ N"*#:/ *- 4( 1*. 1H( :4+/1.9 "(B N*;/*.$L 3$.$O H$ ".$ 0*N: N;1+$. /1 /:$ -:4;1+1-:4N"; -.1C;$0 12 $(;4#:/$(0$(/ 4/+$;2O "+ B4+/4(#*4+:$B 2.10 4/+ &F /:  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f$8$./:$;$++O " N1(N$-/41( 12 *(48$.+";4/9 4+ (1/ .$B*N4C;$ /1 4/+ -"./4N*;". .11/+L '( 4(/$."N/4(# H4/: 1/:$. N1(N$-/41(+ 12 *(48$.+";4/9O " -.1-1+$B *(48$.+";4/9 0"9 C.1"B$( 4/+$;2 4( "--;4N"/41( "(B B4+/"(N$ 4/+$;2 2.10 4/+ -"./4N*;". .11/+O H4/:1*/ C$4(# "C;$ $8$. /1 B4+$(/"(#;$ 4/+$;2 $(/4.$;9 2.10 +*N: .11/+L Y($ 0"9 .$";4U$O 21. $S"0-;$O /:"/ 1($P+ C$;4$2+ "(B N1004/0$(/+ B$.48$ 2.10 1($P+  !"#$ ` -"./4N4-"/41( 4( " N$./"4( +1N41WN*;/*."; #.1*-O "(B /:"/ /:$9 ($8$./:$;$++ .$A*4.$ /:"/ ' /.$"/ 1/:$.+ 12 B422$.$(/ +1N41WN*;/*."; #.1*-+ "NN1.B4(# /1 N$./"4( +/"(B".B+ 12 :*0"( $A*4/9L Y/:$.+ 2.10 B422$.$(/ +1N41WN*;/*."; #.1*-+ 0"9 ";+1 :"8$ -.1-1+$B +/"(B".B+ 12 :*0"( $A*4/9L M:"/ 4+ /1 +"9O /:$.$ ".$ " -;*.";4/9 12 N;"40+ /1 :*0"( *(48$.+";4/9 +*N: /:"/ 4/ 4+ -1++4C;$ /1 $S-;1.$ "( 18$.;"--4(# /$.."4(L _1(+4B$. 4(/$.("/41("; -$"N$L g".41*+ #.1*-+ 0"9 :"8$ " N1004/0$(/ /1 4(/$.("/41("; -$"N$O 0"9 +$$ 4/ (1/ 1(;9 /:.1*#: /:$ ;$(+ 12 +$;2W4(/$.$+/ C*/ "+ " N1(B4/41( "(B $S-.$++41( 12 :*0"( $A*4/9 "(B +/.484(# 21. $SN$;;$(N$L b*/ /:$ +90C1;4N +/.*N/*.$+ /:.1*#: H:4N: /:$9 $S-.$++ /:4+ N1004/0$(/ H4;; ;4<$;9 ";H"9+ B422$.L '( +:1./O /:$.$ .$0"4( " -;*.";4/9 12 ;"(#*"#$+ /:.1*#: H:4N: " /$.."4( 12 +:".$B -."N/4N$ N;"404(# *(48$.+";4/9 4+ N1(+/.*N/$BL ' /:4(< /:"/ /:4+ 4+ (1/ 1(;9 " ;1#4N"; -1++4C4;4/9 C*/ 4+ -.$N4+$;9 /:$ 0$"(4(# 12 /.$"/4$+ "(B H:"/ 0"9 C$ N";;$B  0,$%.%(-$ /#%"&>')%0 L ' :"8$ -.$841*+;9 ".#*$B /:"/ 4/ 4+ .$;"/$B /1 !4$..$W\1+$-: !.1*B:1(P+ "(".N:4+/ N1(N$-/41( 12 2$B$.";4+0L &h  ) N;"++4N $S"0-;$ 4+ /:$ MH1 Z1H >"0-*0 c&[&Vd 4( H:4N: " C4.N:WC".< N"(1$ "(B " ?*.1-$"( +:4- ".$ B$-4N/$B "+ +"4;4(# B1H( /:$ +"0$ .48$.L  &&  )+ ,";$ M*.($. $S-;"4(+O Q/:$ /H1 -"./4N4-"(/+ 4( /:$ -1;4/4N"; .$;"/41(+:4-=?*.1-$"(+ "(B '.1A*14+=N"( +:".$ /:$ +"0$ +-"N$ "(B /."8$; 4(/1 /:$ 2*/*.$O 9$/ ($4/:$. N"( +/$$. /:$ 1/:$.P+ 8$++$;L b$N"*+$ /:$9 +:".$ /:$ +"0$ +-"N$O /:$9 ".$ 4($S/.4N"C;9 $(/H4($B 4( " .$;"/41(+:4- 12 4(/$.B$-$(B$(N$= 21. .)"9 #";-%& >%'.%&(. 0,$%.%(-$ "&.%.%"' LR &T  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b*/ 4/ ";+1 +4/*"/$+ 1($P+ 1H( C$;4$2+ "(B N1004/0$(/+ "+ (1/ ";H"9+ *(48$.+";;9 "--;4N"C;$O /:$.$C9 4(N1.-1."/4(# " N.4/4N"; N10-1($(/O "(B N1(/"4(+ " >1.9   /1 0"4(/"4( /:$ /.$"/9 $8$( H:$( 4/ 4+ (1/ 4( 1($P+ +$;2W4(/$.$+/ /1 B1 +1L b*/ H:$.$ J"(/4"( N1(N$-/ 12 $(;4#:/$(0$(/ 4(81;8$+ .$;$#"/4(# 1($P+ 1H( N1004/0$(/+ /1 /:$ -.48"/$O +$;2W4(/$.$+/$B B10"4(O /:$ /.$"/9 01B$; #"?1%#"' /:$ C$;4$2+ "(B N1004/0$(/+ 12 " N$./"4( +1N41WN*;/*."; #.1*- "+ /:$ 2-'%'  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
Advertisement
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks